Source: The New York Times
Who This Article Is For
This article is written for California residents and anyone managing California-based assets who values transparency, family protection, and understanding how high-profile legal cases can inform their own estate planning and asset protection strategies. If you’re concerned about:
How powerful individuals protect assets through legal structures
What legal privilege means and when it applies in depositions
How to shield your family’s wealth from legal challenges
Understanding the intersection of criminal investigations and estate planning
Then this analysis will help you understand the legal mechanisms at play and how they might apply to your own situation.
What Happened: Maxwell’s House Deposition
On February 9, 2026, Ghislaine Maxwell refused to answer questions during a House deposition regarding her connections to Jeffrey Epstein’s alleged criminal activities. According to The New York Times, Maxwell invoked her Fifth Amendment rights and other legal privileges to avoid providing testimony about:
Her relationship with Jeffrey Epstein
Financial transactions and asset transfers
Interactions with prominent figures linked to Epstein
Knowledge of alleged criminal activities
This development has raised significant questions about legal privilege, asset protection, and how individuals connected to high-profile cases navigate congressional inquiries.
Why Did Maxwell Refuse to Answer Questions?
Maxwell’s refusal to answer questions is rooted in several legal protections available to individuals during depositions and congressional testimony:
1. Fifth Amendment Privilege Against Self-Incrimination
The Fifth Amendment protects individuals from being compelled to testify against themselves in criminal matters. Even in civil or congressional proceedings, witnesses can invoke this right if their answers could:
Expose them to criminal prosecution
Provide evidence that could be used against them in future proceedings
Connect them to illegal activities
California Application: California residents facing depositions in probate litigation, trust disputes, or estate challenges can similarly invoke Fifth Amendment protections when testimony might expose them to criminal liability.
2. Attorney-Client Privilege
Communications between an attorney and client are generally protected from disclosure. Maxwell may have refused to answer questions about conversations with her legal counsel regarding:
Legal strategy and advice
Asset protection planning
Estate and trust structures
3. Spousal Privilege (Historical)
While not applicable in Maxwell’s current situation, spousal privilege historically protected confidential communications between married partners. This principle matters for California families because:
Married couples in California can structure assets to protect against certain legal exposures
Community property laws affect how assets are titled and protected
Estate planning for married couples requires understanding privilege limitations
What California Families Can Learn From High-Profile Cases Like Maxwell’s
The Maxwell deposition illustrates several critical lessons for California residents concerned about asset protection, family wealth preservation, and estate planning:
Lesson 1: Proper Legal Structure Matters Before Problems Arise
High-profile individuals often have sophisticated legal structures in place before facing legal challenges. These structures include:
Revocable living trusts that avoid probate and provide privacy
Irrevocable trusts that remove assets from personal ownership
Limited liability companies (LLCs) that separate personal and business assets
Asset protection trusts that shield wealth from creditors and lawsuits
Real-World Application: A California business owner concerned about liability exposure should establish protective structures while their financial situation is stable—not after a lawsuit is filed.
Lesson 2: Understanding When to Speak and When to Remain Silent
Maxwell’s decision to refuse testimony demonstrates the importance of understanding your legal rights during:
Depositions in probate or trust litigation
Interviews with investigators
Court proceedings involving family wealth
Disputes over estate administration
California families should know: Having experienced legal counsel before making any statements in legal proceedings is essential. What you say can be used against you or your estate.
Lesson 3: Privacy Protections Through Proper Estate Planning
One reason wealthy individuals use trusts rather than wills is privacy. When assets pass through probate (as required by a will), the process becomes:
Public record
Subject to court supervision
Accessible to creditors and challengers
Potentially exposed in legal proceedings
California Solution: A properly funded revocable living trust avoids probate entirely, keeping your family’s financial affairs private and reducing vulnerability to legal challenges.
Lesson 4: The Importance of Documentation and Record-Keeping
In high-profile cases, the documentation trail becomes critical. California families should maintain clear records of:
Trust funding and asset transfers
Gift and estate tax filings
Beneficiary designations
Powers of attorney and healthcare directives
Proper documentation helps defend against claims of fraud, undue influence, or improper asset transfers.
How Can California Residents Protect Their Families Like High-Profile Individuals Do?
While most California families aren’t facing congressional depositions, the same legal principles apply to protecting your wealth and family. Here’s how:
Step 1: Establish a Comprehensive Estate Plan
A complete estate plan for California residents should include:
Revocable Living Trust: Avoids probate, provides privacy, and allows you to control assets during your lifetime
Pour-Over Will: Catches any assets not transferred to your trust
Financial Power of Attorney: Designates someone to manage financial affairs if you’re incapacitated
Advance Healthcare Directive: Specifies your medical wishes and healthcare agent
HIPAA Authorization: Allows designated individuals to access your medical information
Step 2: Consider Asset Protection Strategies
For California families with significant assets or liability exposure, additional protection may include:
Irrevocable Life Insurance Trusts (ILITs): Remove life insurance proceeds from your taxable estate
Qualified Personal Residence Trusts (QPRTs): Transfer your home to heirs at reduced tax cost
Family Limited Partnerships (FLPs): Consolidate family assets and provide valuation discounts
Charitable Remainder Trusts (CRTs): Provide income while supporting charitable causes
Step 3: Regular Review and Updates
Estate plans should be reviewed every 3-5 years or after major life events such as:
Marriage, divorce, or remarriage
Birth or adoption of children
Significant changes in asset values
Changes in California or federal tax laws
Relocation to or from California
Step 4: Work With Experienced California Estate Planning Attorneys
The Maxwell case demonstrates that having knowledgeable legal counsel is essential. Look for attorneys who:
Specialize in California estate planning and probate law
Have experience with complex asset protection strategies
Understand both state and federal estate tax implications
Provide transparent pricing and clear communication
Common Questions California Families Ask About Asset Protection and Legal Privilege
Can I refuse to answer questions in a deposition like Maxwell did?
Yes, you can invoke your Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination if answering could expose you to criminal prosecution. However, this right doesn’t apply to purely civil matters where no criminal liability exists. Always consult with an attorney before making this decision.
Will a trust protect my assets from lawsuits?
A revocable living trust does not provide asset protection from creditors or lawsuits because you maintain control over the assets. However, certain irrevocable trusts and asset protection trusts can shield assets from creditors when properly established before a claim arises.
How can I keep my estate plan private?
Use a revocable living trust instead of a will. Trusts avoid probate, which is a public court process. Properly funded trusts keep your assets, beneficiaries, and distribution plans private.
What happens if I don’t have an estate plan?