Hawaii’s Supreme Court Gun Case: What Families Need to Know About Constitutional Rights and Estate Planning

If you’re concerned about protecting your family’s rights and assets, the recent Supreme Court case Wolford v. Lopez offers critical lessons about constitutional protections that extend beyond gun rights—touching on fundamental freedoms that impact your estate planning strategy.

What Happened in Wolford v. Lopez? Understanding the Constitutional Stakes

On Tuesday, the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments in a landmark Second Amendment case from Hawaii. The state defended a law that would impose up to one year in prison for concealed carry permit holders who enter private property open to the public—like malls or gas stations—without explicit owner permission.

The controversy centers on Hawaii’s reliance on historical “Black Codes”—post-Civil War laws designed to disarm newly freed Black Americans and enable Ku Klux Klan violence.

Why Did Hawaii Cite Racist Historical Laws?

Hawaii’s attorney, Neal Katyal, referenced an 1865 Louisiana Black Code to justify the state’s gun restrictions. Justice Neil Gorsuch expressed astonishment, stating he wanted “to understand how you think black codes should inform this Court’s decision making”.

Justice Samuel Alito questioned the logic directly: “So, is it not the height of irony to cite a law that was enacted for exactly the purpose of preventing someone from exercising the Second Amendment rights, to cite this as an example of what the Second Amendment protects?”

Can States Override Federal Constitutional Rights Based on “Local Custom”?

Justice Sonia Sotomayor suggested Hawaii’s 200-year absence of gun-carrying customs should influence the case. Attorney Alan Beck countered that Hawaii “is part of the United States” and therefore “our national tradition” applies—the Second Amendment protects rights universally, not selectively based on state culture.

The principle is clear: No “custom, tradition, or culture” in a specific state can justify violating the Bill of Rights.

What This Means for California Families Planning Their Estates

While this case focuses on gun rights, the underlying constitutional principle affects all Californians concerned about protecting their families:

Federal rights supersede state customs: Just as Hawaii cannot override Second Amendment protections, California must respect constitutional rights in probate, trust administration, and estate planning.

Historical discrimination cannot justify modern restrictions: The Supreme Court rejected using Black Codes as legal precedent. Similarly, your estate planning shouldn’t be subject to outdated or discriminatory state practices.

Transparency and legal clarity matter: Hawaii’s law creates criminal liability based on property owner silence. In estate planning, ambiguity can lead to probate disputes, family conflict, and asset loss.

How Can California Residents Protect Their Constitutional Rights and Family Legacy?

The Wolford v. Lopez case demonstrates why California families need proactive legal protection:

Establish clear estate documents: Wills, trusts, and powers of attorney ensure your wishes are legally enforceable, preventing state intervention or family disputes.

Understand federal vs. state law: Constitutional protections apply nationwide. Work with attorneys who understand both federal safeguards and California-specific estate planning requirements.

Avoid legal ambiguity: Just as Hawaii’s “silence equals prison” approach creates confusion, unclear estate plans create probate nightmares. Explicit documentation protects your heirs.

Plan for multi-generational asset protection: The case emphasizes rights that extend “from sea to shining sea”. Your estate plan should protect family assets across state lines and generations.

Protect Your Family’s Future with Expert California Estate Planning

California Probate and Trust, PC specializes in comprehensive estate planning for California residents who value transparency, family protection, and constitutional clarity. Our experienced attorneys provide:

Free one-hour consultations to assess your unique family situation

Clear, affordable estate planning packages tailored to your needs

Expert guidance on wills, trusts, probate, and asset protection

Compassionate support through complex legal processes

Whether you’re navigating probate now or planning for your family’s future, we offer the “one-stop-shop” expertise you need to protect what matters most.

Schedule Your Free Consultation Today

Don’t leave your family’s legacy to chance. Contact California Probate and Trust, PC for a no-obligation consultation and take control of your estate planning.

Visit cpt.law or call our Fair Oaks, Sacramento, or San Francisco offices today.

Source: National Review – Hawaii’s Shocking Legal Argument Against the Second Amendment

Legal Disclaimer: This article is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The information presented is based on publicly available court proceedings and news reports. Estate planning and constitutional law are complex areas that require individualized analysis. Readers should consult with a qualified attorney licensed in their jurisdiction before making any legal decisions. California Probate and Trust, PC is available for consultations but this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws and court decisions may change, and the outcome of pending cases cannot be predicted with certainty.